The Hypocrisy of Child Marriage Laws in the U.S

Written by: Zane Miller November 20, 2026

When you think of child marriage, you usually think of this heinous, incredibly taboo practice of small children being married off to old men against their will. While this practice is still common in more patriarchal countries, for the most part, this is not something that you see in the US. Modern debates around “child marriage” mostly center over the legality of older teenagers being allowed to get married before their 18th birthday. This still can cause harm for young individuals, especially young women. Studies have shown that young women getting married as minors in the U.S is associated with poorer mental health, increased abuse and increased risk of poverty.

So does this mean that minors always lack the maturity to get married under all circumstances? Well, not exactly, as there have been some stories of minors getting into positive marriages. For example, PBS Frontline interviewed Lucrecia Villafan, a California attorney who married at 17. Unlike other child marriage stories, Villafan described herself as already “extremely independent” when she decided to marry. She convinced her parents, appeared before a judge, received counseling, and was permitted to marry. Under California law at the time, marriage gave a minor substantial adult legal capacity. Frontline explained that married minors could gain rights such as filing for a restraining order or divorce and accessing certain social services independently. Villafan specifically argued that she had seen marriage help some foster youth by giving them a route toward adult legal independence. Her own outcome was extremely positive. After marrying at 17, Villafan started a family, completed college, graduated from UCLA Law School, became an attorney, had three children, and remained married to the same person decades later. 

Because of the fact that marriage automatically emancipates minors in some states, young people in troubled home situations or who want legal independence sometimes see marriage as the only way to escape an abusive home, or gain adult legal rights. Stories like Villafan’s illustrate how emancipation should be reformed to be more practically accessible to young people who need it. However, this begs the question of why are there so many studies showing how marriage leads to worse outcomes for the minors involved? Simple: the biggest problem with child marriage, is that more often than not, minors are coerced into harmful marriages by parents, religious figures, or other adults in positions of authority.

A peer-reviewed study by Sundari Anitha and Manjusha Gupte, published in Social & Legal Studies, examined life-history interviews with seven American survivors who had been married at 16 or younger, along with interviews with practitioners working on child and forced marriage. The researchers identified direct emotional and physical pressure by parents as a central form of coercion. They also found that coercion could operate through broader power structures involving:

  • parental authority;
  • threats or histories of physical violence;
  • religious expectations;
  • ideas about female virginity, sexuality, honor, and shame;
  • pressure surrounding teenage pregnancy;
  • poverty and dependence;
  • abusive home environments;
  • large age differences between the girl and prospective husband.

The researchers specifically argue that coercion should not be understood only as someone literally saying “marry this person or I will hurt you.” A child’s apparent agreement can occur within circumstances where their realistic ability to refuse is extremely limited, due to being at the lower end of a power imbalance with an oppressive parent or religious community. 

One survivor in the study, Sara, was 15 when her father became involved with a religious sect. Her father was told by the sect’s leader that a 28-year-old man had been chosen for her. Sara described having been raised to believe she was supposed to obey her father, against a background in which avoiding violence also influenced her behavior. The researchers characterize her experience as involving both religious/social coercion and the threat of physical force.

The Tahirih Justice Center conducted one of the first large U.S. studies of forced marriage. More than 500 professionals in 47 states, including attorneys, teachers, counselors, social workers, police, medical professionals and domestic-violence advocates, reported encountering as many as 3,000 known or suspected forced-marriage cases during a two-year period. Many involved girls under 18. Service providers reported coercion involving:

  • intense parental and family pressure;
  • emotional abuse;
  • threats of abandonment;
  • economic threats;
  • social isolation;
  • threats against relatives;
  • physical violence;
  • and, in some cases, death threats.

Tahirih also found that minor victims could be especially vulnerable because they were dependent upon the same parents who were arranging or demanding the marriage. Some victims were reluctant to seek help because they feared getting their parents in trouble, while others faced pressure from both family and their wider community to comply.

Another peer-reviewed U.S. study examined 277 mothers who had experienced intimate-partner violence and sought shelter or justice-system services. Forty-seven (about 17%) reported experiencing an attempted forced marriage. Of those, 45% were under 18 when the forced-marriage attempt occurred. Researchers found that victims who were under 18 experienced more pressure from their parents to marry, as well as greater threats of isolation and economic deprivation. Forced-marriage victims also reported more intimate-partner sexual abuse than the other abused women studied.

Other stories also reflect the same situations. Trevicia Williams was 14 when her mother compelled her to marry a 26-year-old man, with their church involved in the process. She later described the marriage as forced and abusive. Genevieve Meyer was reportedly forced at 15 to marry a 43-year-old man after sexual abuse, in circumstances intended to prevent consequences for the adult. She later escaped the marriage and became an advocate against child marriage. These cases are striking because the harmful marriage wasn’t simply the consequence of two teenagers independently deciding to marry too young. An older adult partner, parent, religious/community authority, or combination of adults played a significant role in forcing and maintaining the marriage.

So the research so far supports the fact that child marriages usually come as a result of harsh coercion by parents, religious communities, and other authority figures, which can make them extremely dangerous for young people. So therefore, these facts taken together should support the idea that any legislation surrounding child marriage should have the primary goal of restricting parents’ power to control a minor’s ability to marry. Since the parents and other adult authority figures are the main threats leading to harmful child marriages, they should be as far away from the decision making process in the minor’s marriages as possible. In short, marriage that is not fully consensual is one of the worst forms of parental oppression.

However, child marriage laws in the US are extremely hypocritical in this regard, as many states actually require parental consent in order for a minor to get married. Alabama allows a person who is at least 16 but under 18 to marry only if the marriage document includes the consent of a parent or guardian. In Louisiana, an officiant cannot marry a 16 or 17-year-old unless the minor has judicial authorization plus written consent from both parents, the minor’s tutor, or the person who has legal custody. Under Utah Code § 81-2-304, a county clerk cannot issue a marriage license to a minor without the signed consent of the minor’s parent or legal guardian, generally given in person. The minor and consenting parent or guardian must also obtain written authorization from a juvenile-court judge or authorized court commissioner. Similarly, In Wyoming, 16 and 17-year-olds generally need both parental or guardian consent and approval from a judge before they can marry. The state does provide an exception for teenagers who have already been legally emancipated

These laws directly contradict the established consensus that parental coercion is the primary driving factor in harmful child marriages. Unfortunately, these states choose to value “parental rights” over the actual safety of children who are more likely to be coerced into harmful situations due to these laws. By requiring parental consent to allow minors to marry, these states create two major harms. First of all, this empowers abusive and controlling parents to be able to force their children into marriages that will harm them. Second of all, it requires minors who want to escape their abusive home environments to be reliant on their very abuser in order to access their way out. Child marriage researchers and advocacy organizations have repeatedly pointed out an inherent problem: if the parent is the person trying to force the child into marriage, requiring that parent’s approval does nothing to protect the child. UNICEF USA explicitly notes that in child marriage cases, parental consent requirements can effectively become parental coercion, particularly in situations involving pregnancy, financial instability, or other pressures affecting the family’s decision. Therefore, requiring parental consent for minors’ marriage is inherently harmful, dangerous, and should not be part of any child marriage law. 

When researching for this article, I watched the documentary America’s Child Brides (BBC, 2019), which primarily follows three girls/women whose experiences illustrate very different types of under-18 marriage in the United States: Keri, Heather, and Zion. The documentary uses their stories to contrast coercive marriages involving much older men with a voluntary teenage marriage that the couple regarded positively.

Keri was 15 years old in South Carolina when she became pregnant by 24-year-old Paul. Because of their ages, Paul potentially faced investigation for statutory rape. According to Keri, Paul believed that marrying her could make the criminal investigation disappear or protect him from prosecution. Keri initially did not want to marry him. She said Paul approached her father for permission and won his approval by giving him a case of beer—as her father struggled with alcoholism. Under South Carolina law at the time, pregnancy and parental consent could permit a girl under 16 to marry. This story showed how even though the girl was in a harmful situation and she specifically did not want to marry, she was forced into a marriage by her father, who was literally bribed into agreeing by the abuser giving him a case of beer. This is a disturbing instance of a parent’s addiction leading to the worst possible case scenario for a vulnerable young person. 

Heather was 14 and living in Idaho when she became involved with 24-year-old Aaron, whom she met after he began working around her family’s fishing-tackle business. Heather described one night when she became intoxicated and passed out in Aaron’s trailer. The next morning, Aaron told her that they had had sex. She later discovered that she was pregnant. Heather’s mother contacted police because she believed Aaron had committed statutory rape. Heather’s father, however, believed that because Heather was pregnant, marriage was the appropriate response. Abortion was rejected by the family for religious reasons, and the adults discussed marriage as a way to create a family for the expected baby. Idaho’s restrictions made the marriage difficult, so Heather’s father drove Heather and Aaron roughly 24 hours from Idaho to Missouri, where the marriage could occur with parental consent. Heather’s mother was not told beforehand. Heather was married shortly after turning 15. Heather described herself as heavily “influenced” by her family, and feeling that refusing could result in people going to jail. In other words, her eventual “agreement” existed under enormous family and legal pressure.

The way that marriage was used to cover up Heather’s rape is even more disturbing. The situation with Heather was already rape, and would have been rape even if she was a legal adult, due to the fact she was inebriated and potentially unconscious and therefore unable to consent. This shouldn’t have just been statutory rape charges—there should have also been charges of sexual assault of an incapacitated indivdual—which would have made Aaron a criminal regardless of the family’s pressure for marriage. The statutory rape exception that occured in Keri’s case is another example of how child marriage laws in the US can be inherently hypocritical. Marriage should not have a bearing on whether or not someone is too young to consent for sex, and child marriage laws including statutory rape exceptions is actually further incentivizing abusers to pressure children into forced marriages to avoid consequences for their actions.

These stories further showcase how most harmful child marriages are coerced by families. In both instances, the young person in question who was being forced into the marriage was self aware enough to know that this was a harmful situation for them—with Keri even specifically not wanting to be married—despite her father forcing her into it after receiving beer. These are not cases of young people making a mistake or not being mature enough to understand marriage—these are cases of state laws systematically empowering abusive parents to force children into marriages against their will. These girls’ heartbreaking stories should not be taken as evidence that minors should not be allowed to exercise autonomy in relationships, they should be taken as evidence of why child marriage laws should focus on keeping parental consent far away from the requirements, in order to fight family coercion. 

The other story in the documentary, Zion, actually provided a positive instance of a young woman getting married as a minor. Zion and David began dating as teenagers. Zion was about 14 when their relationship began, while David was approximately two years older. Zion became pregnant at 16, and the two decided that they wanted to marry. Unlike Keri and Heather, David was not a substantially older adult and no coercion by parents was present. The documentary portrays Zion as genuinely wanting the marriage. Zion was in love, wanted to marry, and remained happy with that choice. There was also a major practical reason for marriage. David was serving in the military, and marriage allowed Zion and their child to live with him as a family on a military base. Without marrying, Zion believed that a blanket marriage age of 18 could have forced the young family to live separately for approximately two years. Zion therefore opposed the idea that every marriage under 18 should automatically be treated as equivalent to cases such as Heather’s. 

Her story showed that minors can be mature, want to build families, and have the competence to marry into a non-harmful situation that is beneficial to their life. The part that stuck out to me the most is that there is a complete absence of coercion by parents or any other abusive or controlling authority figure—unlike in the other two girls’ cases. These stories show me one thing—when minors can marry out of their own free will to gain legal rights, without coercion, this can be beneficial to them—but when any amount of parental pressure is present, the marriage becomes extremely harmful. 

Ideally, instead of having child marriage be reinforced as the only way a minor can gain legal independence or escape an abusive home, emancipation should instead be reformed to make it much more accessible for youth. Emancipation provides a safer alternative to child marriage, without the risk of putting a young person in a situation with an unhealthy power imbalance. All in all, child marriage can have many harms and negative affects for young people, due to parental and family coercion. However, the biggest flaw in current child marriage legislation in the US, is the fact that parental consent is still held as a requirement—when parental coercion is the primary driving factor in making child marriages dangerous. Parental consent should never be considered in child marriage laws, and child marriage laws should be primarily focused on preventing coercive marriages that are forced onto youth by oppressive families, instead of punishing youth who seek non-coerced marriage.

The National Youth Rights Association

If you’re interested in Youth Rights, consider volunteering with us. We are always looking for new members and would love to have you on board. If you have a personal story to share, of being a victim of oppressive parental coercion into marriage, or about a general youth rights violation, consider sending us an email at nyra@youthrights.org. We’d love to help get your story out to the world.

The text of The Hypocrisy of Child Marriage Laws in the U.S © 2026 by Zane Miller is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *