Law Enforcement Failing Youth

In many ways, American law enforcement has fallen short in its treatment of youth. One of the major ways this can occur, is by law enforcement not taking youth seriously when it comes to them reporting abuse, mistreatment, or other harmful situations that they are living in. This is especially likely to occur in situations where the parents are responsible for the abuse. There have been many cases of young people escaping abusive households, reporting abuse to child protective services, or attempting to seek support from law enforcement. However, instead of believing them and taking the concerns of the young people seriously, the law enforcement officers and child protective services would often take the side of the abusive parents. Because of this, they often accused the young person of lying, faking accusations or attempting to evade parental discipline. This has led to vulnerable children being returned to abusive homes where they are harmed or killed, taken into custody for running away, or ignored by child protective services. In certain incidents, teenagers reporting abuse during a custody battle and refusing to visit the abusive parent led to them being arrested by law enforcement, instead of the abuse being investigated. These situations illustrate how young people are not taken seriously, and that the presumption of parental authority harms young people facing dangerous circumstances at home. 

Along with this, law enforcement often prioritizes punitive control over supportive rehabilitation through policing practices, including officers’ presence in schools. Interactions with law enforcement and the juvenile justice system can have long-lasting consequences, including disrupted education, criminal records that restrict future opportunities, psychological trauma, and diminished overall well-being. Although more than half of U.S. states have refined their juvenile justice systems since 2000, with most moving away from punitive approaches, the United States continues to incarcerate more young people than any other industrialized nation. This paradox is driven in part by the criminalization of everyday student behavior and deep racial disparities in how minority youth are treated. Ultimately, this issue highlights a fundamental tension between law enforcement’s responsibility to maintain public safety and the need to ensure the fair and ethical treatment of youth.


Table of contents


Back to Top

The National Youth Rights Association

If you’re interested in Youth Rights, consider volunteering with us. We are always looking for new members and would love to have you on board. If you have a personal story to share, of police violence and mistreatment of youth, about law enforcement not taking you seriously while you were young, or about a general youth rights violation, consider sending us an email at nyra@youthrights.org. We’d love to help get your story out to the world.


Back to Top

When Law Enforcement Fails to Believe Youth or Take them Seriously

Law enforcement has repeatedly failed to take youth seriously when they seek protection or report abuse. Children and teenagers who report sexual assault, domestic violence, parental mistreatment, or other dangerous circumstances may encounter officers who dismiss their concerns, question their credibility, or fail to conduct adequate investigations. These problems can be especially serious when the alleged abuser is a parent or guardian. Because adults possess greater authority over their children, young people can find themselves in situations where police accept their parents’ explanations without adequately investigating the child’s account. Consequently, children who turn to law enforcement for protection can be left without help, subjected to retaliation, or returned to the same environments they were attempting to escape.

Research indicates that these experiences are not limited to isolated incidents. A 2022 study published in the Journal of Interpersonal Violence examined 244 text-based crisis-service conversations involving people reporting child maltreatment. Researchers found that many young people were reluctant to seek help from law enforcement because they believed officers would not take their concerns seriously or would be unable or unwilling to protect them. Some described negative experiences with police, including one young person who reported, “I tried going through the police and they have done nothing to help.” Another described running away from an abusive situation and calling police, only to feel that officers did not believe their account. Particularly concerning were accounts in which young people believed officers were more likely to accept their parents’ explanations, including a child who feared that their mother would falsely accuse them of initiating a physical confrontation and that police would believe her instead.

Similarly, a 2024 study conducted by researchers affiliated with the Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network (RAINN) examined 124 anonymous hotline conversations involving young people whose sexual abuse continued after they had previously disclosed it to a mandated reporter. In 71% of these cases, the abuse was apparently never reported to the appropriate authorities or was not investigated. In another 24%, an investigation occurred but failed to provide protection. Some young people reported that investigators sided with the alleged perpetrators or dismissed allegations because they believed there was insufficient evidence. Others described being pressured into recanting their accounts, sometimes because they feared retaliation. Although this research examined failures across child-protection systems rather than police alone, it demonstrates how authorities’ unwillingness to believe young victims can allow abuse to continue even after children attempt to seek help. These percentages describe the selected hotline cases, not all child abuse reports nationwide.

One particularly disturbing example occurred in Yates County, New York, when a teenage girl reported in May 2023 that her adoptive father had been sexually assaulting her since 2021. The case was assigned to investigator Megan Morehouse of the Yates County Sheriff’s Office, who admitted during an accidentally recorded conversation that she did not believe the teenager. Morehouse subsequently failed to take basic investigative steps recommended by the district attorney, including obtaining search warrants for the father’s phone and home. Nearly two months after the initial report, Child Protective Services returned the girl to her adoptive father’s home, where she was reportedly blamed for disrupting the family and subjected to additional sexual assaults. After she reported the abuse again, the investigation was transferred to the New York State Police. In September 2025, the father pleaded guilty to a felony sexual assault charge involving a child. Despite the investigative failures, Morehouse faced relatively limited disciplinary consequences.

A similar case arose in Umatilla, Oregon, when a 13-year-old girl and her family reported that a 34-year-old man had sexually assaulted her, recorded the abuse, and threatened her family. According to a subsequent lawsuit, Detective Sergeant Bill Wright dismissed the teenager’s account despite being provided with video evidence, allegedly stating that young girls frequently fabricate sexual assault allegations. Rather than adequately investigating the evidence, Wright reportedly demanded additional identifying information about the suspect, leaving the teenager to spend approximately two years gathering evidence herself while the perpetrator continued threatening her. Her family eventually contacted the FBI, which arrested the suspect in 2020. He was later convicted of producing child sexual abuse material and sentenced to 25 years in prison. The teenager subsequently sued Umatilla police officials, alleging that their failure to investigate had prolonged her victimization.

Beyond failing to investigate allegations, law enforcement has sometimes actively criminalized children who report being victimized. One such case involved Danielle Hicks-Best, an 11-year-old girl in Washington, D.C., who reported being raped on two separate occasions in 2008. Despite medical evidence supporting allegations of sexual assault, police failed to adequately investigate the reports and never arrested the suspected perpetrators. Instead, investigators treated the girl with extreme skepticism, questioned her in ways that violated established procedures for interviewing child sexual assault victims, and ultimately had her charged with filing a false police report. She was convicted and subsequently spent years moving between juvenile detention and treatment facilities. Following reporting by The Washington Post, police leadership acknowledged investigative errors and ordered a new investigation. Her experience illustrates how a child’s request for protection can become the basis for punishment when officers disregard the credibility and vulnerability of young victims.


Back to Top

Presumption of Parental Authority with Law Enforcement; When Police Believe Abusive Parents over Youth

Unfortunately, there is a default presumption of parental authority in our society, which means that parents are generally seen as the ones in the right, while youth may be seen as unruly or delinquent. This can often lead police to accept an abusive parent’s explanation over the child’s own account. In October 2024, nine-year-old Rebekah Baptiste escaped her home in Phoenix, Arizona, and fled to a gas station, telling employees that her father’s girlfriend was abusing her. Police responded, and Rebekah reported that she had repeatedly been struck with brushes and belts and subjected to physically demanding exercises as punishment. Officers documented bruising and injuries on her hands and feet that appeared consistent with portions of her account. However, when investigators questioned her father and his girlfriend, the adults denied the abuse and claimed that Rebekah had inflicted the injuries on herself. Police ultimately declined to pursue criminal charges, citing conflicting accounts and insufficient evidence, and the girl was discharged back into her father’s care. Nine months later, in July 2025, Rebekah died after suffering extensive injuries that prosecutors attributed to prolonged abuse. Her father and his girlfriend were subsequently charged with murder and child abuse. The case is particularly troubling because the child’s allegations were not merely verbal: officers had photographed physical injuries, and authorities had received multiple previous reports concerning her safety.

Another example occurred in San Antonio, Texas, where five-year-old Mercedes Losoya suffered prolonged abuse at the hands of her mother and her mother’s boyfriend. In January 2022, a neighbor contacted police after hearing a child screaming in apparent pain during what sounded like a beating. San Antonio police responded to the apartment but did not enter the residence or personally examine Mercedes. Instead, they accepted explanations from the adults, who characterized the child as disobedient and suggested that she was simply overreacting to ordinary punishment. Mercedes later died after suffering extensive physical abuse. Investigators subsequently uncovered recordings documenting the violence, and both adults received lengthy prison sentences. Former San Antonio police detective Lawrence Saiz later acknowledged that authorities had failed Mercedes and advocated for improved police training in child welfare investigations. The incident demonstrates the danger of treating a parent’s characterization of a child as sufficient reassurance without independently examining the child’s safety.

These problems also arise when police encounter young people who have run away from home. While officers may regard runaway youth as disobedient children who need to be returned to their parents, running away can itself be a response to abuse, neglect, or other unsafe circumstances. A 2012 study published in the federally supported Journal of Juvenile Justice examined police screening records involving 269 runaway youth between the ages of nine and seventeen. Researchers found that some young people explicitly reported running away because they were being abused at home, yet were nevertheless returned to their parents or guardians by police. The researchers were unable to determine whether officers subsequently notified child protective services or conducted additional investigations, raising concerns about whether returning these children home placed them at further risk. The study highlighted the importance of viewing runaway youth as potentially vulnerable victims rather than automatically treating their behavior as delinquency. These instances illustrate the importance of young people having basic runaway rights, and how running away should not be treated as a crime where law enforcement should punish young people and return them to their parents. 

Law enforcement’s tendency to prioritize parental authority can also harm young people in custody disputes, even when they report emotional mistreatment rather than physical violence. In a firsthand account published by The Washington Post, twin sisters Hope and Elizabeth Loudon described how they were handcuffed and taken to juvenile detention at age fourteen after refusing to comply with a custody arrangement requiring them to live part-time with their father. The sisters reported experiencing considerable emotional distress in their father’s home and believed that living with their mother would be safer for their psychological well-being. When they sought assistance from a school police officer, they said he and a school administrator dismissed their concerns, characterized their father as loving, and presented them with an ultimatum: return to their father or be arrested. The sisters refused and were subsequently detained. They reported that officials repeatedly dismissed their experiences because they could not demonstrate physical injuries. Although their father disputed their characterization of his behavior, the sisters’ account highlights how police enforcement of parental custody arrangements can override children’s expressed concerns and subject them to punishment without any criminal wrongdoing.

These concerns extend to situations where children report parental abuse during contentious custody proceedings. A 2023 ProPublica investigation documented the case of a young Colorado boy whose reports of physical and sexual abuse by his father were repeatedly brought to authorities by medical professionals, educators, and other mandated reporters. Despite these reports, a sheriff’s investigator suggested that the allegations were being manufactured by the boy’s mother as part of a custody dispute. The officer’s report attributed the complaints to the mother’s supposed efforts to interfere with custody, even though multiple reports originated with independent professionals. A second officer who reviewed the case expressed concern that investigators had failed to pursue substantial evidence, including photographs of injuries and accounts from medical providers. Although the underlying abuse allegations remained disputed, the case illustrates how assumptions about parental custody conflicts can influence police assessments of a child’s credibility and discourage investigation of potentially serious harm.

In addition to mistreatment within the home, young people can be disregarded when they disappear or are reported missing. An investigation published by InvestigateWest in 2024 documented the disappearance of Kit Nelson-Mora, a 16-year-old Indigenous and nonbinary teenager in Washington state. Kit’s mother reportedly told authorities that the teenager had run away, but other relatives and friends questioned that explanation and raised concerns about the safety of the home. Despite warnings received by law enforcement, school officials, and child protective services, authorities failed to establish an adequate investigation for months. It took more than a year after Kit’s last known communications for police to seriously investigate their disappearance. The case demonstrates how accepting a parent’s explanation that a child has simply run away can delay efforts to locate young people who may be in danger.

These incidents highlight a broader failure to recognize young people as credible individuals who deserve protection independently of their parents’ wishes or authority. When officers assume that children are exaggerating, lying, misbehaving, or attempting to undermine parental discipline, legitimate reports of abuse can be disregarded and children can be returned to dangerous environments. Even when mistreatment does not involve visible physical injuries, dismissing a child’s account without conducting a meaningful investigation can cause serious psychological harm and discourage future attempts to seek help. Law enforcement should approach reports made by youth with the same seriousness afforded to adults, independently investigate conflicting accounts, and recognize that parental authority does not automatically establish parental credibility. Failing to do so can transform the very institutions responsible for protecting young people into additional obstacles preventing them from escaping abuse.


Back to Top

Police Presence in Schools and the School-to-Prison Pipeline 

The Role of Police in Schools and the Criminalization of Student Behavior

Although a primary justification for placing police in schools is to deter school shootings, research shows they do not effectively prevent them. Additionally, studies indicate that School Resource Officers (SROs) tend to prioritize law enforcement roles over mentoring and education which are also part of their responsibilities. In these environments, police-youth contact occurs during routine interactions, school events, and security checks. While some encounters are minor and resolved informally, others escalate into arrests or referrals to the juvenile justice system.

The presence of SROs can result in more student behaviors being criminalized rather than handled internally. Student arrests are overwhelmingly for minor violations that could easily be addressed by school administrators. For instance, one in every six student arrests in New York schools is for resisting arrest by an SRO or “obstructing governmental administration”—charges that would never have occurred if an officer had not been present in the first place. The presence of SROs also means that minor hallway scuffles are frequently elevated to assault charges. Consequently, schools with SROs record five times more disorderly conduct arrests than schools without them, and during the 2017–2018 school year, approximately 4.5 students were referred to law enforcement for every 1,000 students enrolled in public schools. Additionally, a report found 24 cases of sexual assault against students and 5 students deaths resulting from police force in schools.


Back to Top

Racial and Disability-Based Disparities in School Policing

In predominantly Black and Hispanic schools, the role of SROs often emphasizes policing and punishing children rather than supporting them. Consequently, Black students account for a disproportionate number of school suspensions. According to a report by the Center for the Study of Race and Equity in Education, 1.2 million Black K–12 students were suspended nationwide in a single academic year. This disparity is frequently driven by the implicit biases of educators, administrators, and SROs, who may unfairly perceive Black children as unruly or violent. As a result, Black students are often punished more harshly than their white peers for similar infractions. For instance, Black students are more likely to be suspended for subjective behaviors like “disrespect,” whereas white students are more often disciplined for objective infractions such as smoking or vandalism. 

These disparities are particularly stark for Black girls, as they are three times more likely than white girls to be referred to law enforcement, over five times more likely to be suspended at least once, and seven times more likely to receive multiple out-of-school suspensions. Ultimately, higher rates of discretionary discipline can lead to higher rates of student arrests. Students with disabilities face similar harms from school policing. Although students with disabilities make up roughly 12% to 14% of student enrollment, they account for more than a quarter (26% to 28%) of students arrested or referred to law enforcement. Without specialized training on how to de-escalate situations involving students with disabilities, officers can criminalize disability-related behaviors and file unnecessary charges.

Beyond referrals and arrests, one study found that Black students accounted for 80% of reported incidents of police violence in schools and at least 60% of these incidents resulted in serious injuries.  Although Black students are often unfairly viewed as the problem, they are actually the ones most harmed. Black girls, in particular, are disproportionately impacted by school policing. Compared to their white peers, they are four times more likely to be arrested and twice as likely to be physically restrained. According to Tyler Whittenberg, deputy director at the Advancement Project, “When they [Black students] attend schools where they’re seen as a threat and are targeted by police officers as they walk to and from their classes, what else would they take away from that other than, ‘This system is really not meant for me’?”

Importantly, in most cases where officers have assaulted students, they have faced no consequences. Only 10% of cases resulted in any form of discipline, which was more often reassignment or an internal review rather than termination.


Back to Top

The Educational and Psychological Consequences of School Policing

Policies that favor law enforcement and punishment over support increase a student’s likelihood of entering the juvenile justice system. This occurs largely because the growing presence of School Resource Officers (SROs) funnels students into the criminal justice system, thereby facilitating the school-to-prison pipeline. According to the ACLU, this pipeline “refers to the policies and practices that push our nation’s schoolchildren, especially our most at-risk children, out of classrooms and into the juvenile and criminal justice systems. This pipeline reflects the prioritization of incarceration over education.”  A single encounter with the juvenile system can create a juvenile record that causes more severe sanctions if the child gets in trouble again, regardless of whether it’s a minor offense.

Criminalizing student conduct is deeply harmful to youth, because they are still developing and have a greater capacity for change than adults. Extensive research shows that behavioral issues often stem from developing adolescent judgment as well as trauma linked to circumstances such as poverty, family substance abuse and gang violence. Because students facing these social and emotional struggles are more likely to act out, a heavy presence of SROs leads to frequent police encounters that exacerbate their psychological harm. Research also shows that increased interaction with law enforcement acts as a source of stress; even well-trained SROs can negatively impact a child’s psychological and physical well-being simply by increasing the level of policing and surveillance students experience. Furthermore, higher rates of police interaction are closely linked to depression and anxiety in youth. While being stopped at school by officers has been tied to heightened emotional distress and post-traumatic stress symptoms.


Back to Top

Documented Cases of School Police Misconduct

Examples of school policing  practices that disproportionately affect Black students include a six-year-old Black girl being escorted by police with her hands zip-tied behind her back for having a temper tantrum, a Black girl being sent to juvenile detention for failing to complete her online homework, and a 12-year-old Black girl being searched for contraband because her principal thought she looked “too chipper and excited.”  

In an even more violent case at Spring Valley High School in South Carolina in 2015, a school resource officer placed a Black female student in a headlock, flipped her over her desk, and dragged and threw her across the classroom. This escalation occurred merely because she was accused of being disruptive and refused to surrender her phone during class.


Back to Top

Racial Disparities in the Policing and Incarceration of Youth

Racial Disparities in Police Encounters and the Adultification of Black Youth

Black children face disproportionate treatment during police encounters. In an analysis by the Associated Press of more than 3,000 incidents where police used force against children under 16, they found that over half of the children were Black, even though they represent just 15% of the U.S. child population. This disparate treatment often stems from harmful racial perceptions. When Black youth engage in normal adolescent behavior, adults frequently view them as more threatening and treat them as older than they are. Researchers call this phenomenon “adultification.” A study supporting this finding says that Black boys are overestimated in age by an average of 4.5 years, causing them to be perceived as older and less innocent than their white peers.


Back to Top

Racial Disparities Throughout the Juvenile Justice System

Racial disparities extend beyond police encounters and into the juvenile justice system, where Black youth are more likely than white youth to receive harsher sanctions. Following an arrest, Black youth are more likely to be detained, whereas white youth are more frequently diverted from formal system involvement. Similarly, white youth are more likely to receive probation or informal sanctions, while Black youth are far more likely to be incarcerated. 

These disparities persist even as overall youth incarceration has declined significantly over the past few decades. Between 2000 and 2023, the number of youth held in juvenile justice facilities, adult prisons, and adult jails fell by 74 percent. Despite these overall drops, youth of color continue to face much higher incarceration rates than white youth. In 2023, white youth were held in juvenile facilities at a rate of 52 per 100,000, compared with 293 per 100,000 for Black youth, making Black youth 5.6 times more likely to be held in custody. Native youth were 3.8 times more likely to be incarcerated than white youth and Latino youth were 25 percent more likely. Even though Black youth represent a minority in the youth population, they remain disproportionately overrepresented in the justice system. These deep disparities stem from a combination of differing offending rates and unequal treatment at multiple points of contact within the justice system. 

The persistence of these disparities is also evident at the state level. While overall juvenile placements dropped by 46% over the 10-year period ending in 2023, Black-white disparities in youth incarceration actually increased by more than 10% across 23 states. Furthermore, The Sentencing Project notes that “Black youth were at least 10 times as likely to be held in placement as white youth in New Jersey, Connecticut, Nebraska, Wisconsin, Massachusetts, Utah, Illinois, New York, Oklahoma, Colorado, and Delaware.”

These broader disparities are also reflected in individual cases of disproportionate policing and criminalization of Black children. One such incident gained national attention in 2021, after a YouTube video surfaced of an off-campus scuffle between two young boys. In response, Murfreesboro police sought juvenile petitions against 10 children who had merely watched the fight. Officers arrived at Hobgood Elementary School in Tennessee and arrested four Black children, handcuffing at least one by mistake and terrifying students who had never thrown a punch. To justify the arrests, police and judicial commissioners charged the children with “criminal responsibility for conduct of another.” The Rutherford County District Attorney later confirmed that no such criminal charge exists under Tennessee law, and the arrests and subsequent jailing subjected young students to solitary confinement, a practice linked to severe psychological trauma. 


Back to Top

Rehabilitation Over Punishment: Rethinking Youth Justice

The practice of treating young offenders differently from adults began in the 19th century. This shift was driven by a growing belief that rehabilitation should take priority over punishment, and that education was the best way to correct delinquent behavior. Later, the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act of 1974 established a federal office dedicated to juvenile justice improvements and preventing delinquency. Federal funding has continued to support juvenile education as a core tool for rehabilitation.

In the 2005 case Roper v. Simmons, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the death penalty is unconstitutional for juvenile offenders, finding that it violates the Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment. While that ruling left the door open for life sentences without parole, the Court narrowed those boundaries in subsequent cases. In Graham v. Florida (2010), the Court banned life without parole for juveniles convicted of non-homicide crimes, and in Miller v. Alabama (2012), it ruled that mandatory life-without-parole sentences for juveniles, even in homicide cases, are also unconstitutional.

Each U.S. state has its own juvenile sentencing laws as well as the authority to transfer youth to the adult criminal justice system. Although the dominant outlook in the 21st century has been to promote juvenile rehabilitation and reintegration into society, approximately 2,250 youth were held in adult jails and prisons in 2021. Research shows that sentencing youth as adults does not deter crime, whereas placing them in programs is far more effective. Youth rehabilitation programs allow young people to continue their education, prioritize their mental health through counseling, and reduce their likelihood of re-entering the justice system. In contrast, charging youth as adults and placing them in adult correctional facilities can severely harm their mental health, often leaving them in worse condition than when they entered.

Because laws require youth in adult facilities to be separated from adults, they can often be placed in solitary confinement, which as previously stated worsens their mental health. Conversely, when youth are housed alongside adults, they face a much higher risk of sexual assault and suicide, making youth rehabilitation programs a safer and better alternative. Additionally, research shows that 17-year-olds sentenced as juveniles and sent to youth rehabilitation programs have a higher chance of finding employment and faring better later in life. Young people tried as adults, however, may carry adult convictions on their records, which makes it difficult to secure employment and housing. Ultimately increasing their chances of reoffending.